Blog

UncategorizedWhy Artists Are Self-Producing (and Succeeding) More Than Ever — And Why The Orchard Project Is Stepping In

Why Artists Are Self-Producing (and Succeeding) More Than Ever — And Why The Orchard Project Is Stepping In

If you squint at the arts landscape right now, you’ll see something counterintuitive happening. Yes, the theater, film, and performance industries are in contraction. Yes, producing opportunities are scarce. Yes, institutions are risk-averse.

And yet — some of the most interesting, important, and culture-shifting artists of the last decade have broken through because they took matters into their own hands.

When pathways narrow, artists build new ones. We’re watching that happen in real time.


Self-Production Isn’t the Back Door — It’s Becoming the Front Door

For years, institutions liked to pretend there was one “proper” path: development → workshop → reading → producer → production. But when fewer producers are producing and fewer theaters are mounting new work, that ladder has collapsed. So artists are building their own.

And let’s be honest: “just self-produce” can sound like someone saying “just build a house.” It’s thrilling — and intimidating. Where do you start? How do you raise the money? Who holds the contracts? What about payroll, insurance, unions, fiscal sponsorship, marketing, and the thousand invisible details that can stop a brilliant piece before it reaches the public? The stakes are real: when the system offers fewer on-ramps, the burden shifts to artists — and without infrastructure, even extraordinary work can stall out right at the moment it’s ready.

URGENT THOUGHT: Gatekeepers aren’t the only amplifiers anymore. What do they know — your ability to build community, spark conversation, and go viral might be the better ROI.

 Real-world artists who broke through because they self-produced
These are not anomalies or charming origin stories. They are proof points in a systemic shift.

Rachel Chavkin (OP 08,09,11)
Before she was a Tony-winning director of Hadestown, she built her own performance vocabulary through the TEAM — a scrappy, self-producing collective that carved out an aesthetic without waiting for permission.

Tina Satter (OP 13, 20)
Half Straddle’s DIY path led to Is This A Room — premiering at JACK, moving to Vineyard, and becoming one of the most acclaimed Broadway transfers in recent memory. The road began in self-production.

Celine Song (OP 19)
Before Past Lives, she made The Seagull on The Seagull on The Seagull — a devised, low-budget, self-driven project outside the system.

Jeremy O. Harris (OP 18)
Slave Play began with self-generated work; his ascent is inseparable from a willingness to make the thing anyway, outside traditional corridors.

And the list goes on: Sam Pinkleton & Pig Iron, Manual Cinema, Whitney White, Will Arbery, Claudia Rankine, Dave Malloy, Taylor Mac, Young Jean Lee — and many more.


Sundance and the Age of Bootstrapped Cinema

The film world tells an even clearer story: The Blair Witch Project (famously made for $35,000), Tangerine (shot on an iPhone), Thunder Road (crowdfunded/self-distributed), Shiva Baby (built from a thesis short), and more.

DID YOU KNOW?
“Most breakout Sundance films were made for under $1M. Many for under $200k.”

The lesson? The work wins when the work is undeniable — and self-production is often the only way to give the work a chance to exist.


And Then There’s Edinburgh — The Great Equalizer

Every year in Edinburgh, you see the next decade of culture being born — often in 50-seat black boxes, pubs, parking lots, and hallways-turned-theaters.

Most of the shows that eventually win awards, transfer, or go global are self-produced.

Edinburgh remains one of the most democratic stages on earth. But “democratic” doesn’t mean “accessible.” It still requires money, structure, production support, and often a nonprofit fiscal sponsor — obstacles that stop many brilliant artists before they begin.

DID YOU KNOW?
“Over 60% of Edinburgh Fringe transfers in the past 10 years came from self-produced shows.”


The Discovery Problem — and Why Artists Can’t Wait for Institutions to “Find” Them

For decades, one reason artists needed producers wasn’t just money — it was discovery. Institutions were gatekeepers, but they were also amplifiers. But the discovery ecosystem is broken too.

Even $50,000 in paid advertising doesn’t guarantee anyone will attend your show.

Meanwhile, artists are building their own discovery pipelines: viral monologues, mailing lists, mutual support networks, micro-touring, podcasts and audio trailers, hybrid sharing, and crowdfunding campaigns that are themselves marketing tools.

CALL-OUT: Discovery is no longer guaranteed by signing with a theater or producer — and it cannot be bought reliably.


But let’s also be honest: self-producing can feel terrifying.

It’s one thing to say “just make the work yourself,” and another to feel the weight of the questions that follow: How do I raise the money? Where do I even begin? Who handles payroll? Do I need insurance? Is there a template for a contract? What if I mess something up? What if I can’t get an audience? What if no one comes?

For many artists, the creative part isn’t the hurdle — it’s the mountain of logistics, finances, legalities, and administrative decisions that no one ever taught them to navigate. And that fear isn’t irrational; without support, self-producing can be financially risky, emotionally draining, and structurally inequitable. The stakes feel impossibly high because, for most artists, they really are. Which is exactly why this moment demands new scaffolding, not new pressure.

This Is Exactly Why We Are Launching the Orchard Project Opportunity Fund

Not as a grant program. Not as a prize. Not as a competition.
But as infrastructure.

The Opportunity Fund will provide:

  • Fee-free fiscal sponsorship
  • Fundraising support and strategy
  • Budget help
  • Payroll and insurance scaffolding
  • Contracting, union, and legal help
  • Marketing guidance rooted in contemporary audience behavior
  • Cohort-based learning
  • And in select cases: direct financial support

It is for artists who are ready to step into production — whether that means a DIY run, a self-produced workshop, a microbudget tour, a festival engagement, or a bold new idea that institutions simply aren’t ready for yet.

“Artists are innovating at an astonishing rate — not just in how they make work, but in how they get that work seen… We want to give them tools, support, and community so the work doesn’t stall out at the exact moment it’s ready for an audience.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top

The Orchard Project (OP) is a preeminent artistic development laboratory and accelerator for creators of performance and dramatic stories.

Where to find us

PO Box 237091

New York, NY 10023

646 760 6767 x 101

Social